Added to Cart!
View Cart

Why not? Roasting at origin vs. roasting in the end market

The vast majority of specialty coffee companies don’t roast their beans in the country of origin. Instead, they roast them closer to home, in the markets where the coffee is sold. We do the same. But why?

Long transport routes and regional market differences have had a significant influence on our decision.

In this article, you’ll find all the details, including a short interview with our master roaster and Head of Coffee, Hannes.

How do green coffee beans and roasted coffee differ in terms of transportation?

Roasted coffee beans are significantly more sensitive than green coffee. During roasting, numerous chemical processes take place that fundamentally change the beans. For example, the darker a coffee is roasted, the more lipids rise to the surface, where they oxidize through direct contact with oxygen. When these lipids deteriorate, the coffee is still safe to consume, but it is no longer enjoyable.

This is where it becomes clear that roasted coffee requires careful handling. The longer roasted beans are stored, the more gases they release. Every coffee has a “sweet spot” — a point at which it tastes its best. Once the coffee has degassed, meaning it has been stored for too long, it starts to taste flat. Lightly roasted coffees release fewer lipids than darker roasts and therefore take longer to degas. This sensitivity is one of the main reasons why coffee is almost exclusively roasted in the end market.

In most cases, the beans are transported to the end market by sea — from Ethiopia to Berlin, for example. The journey often takes three months. If there are delays due to geopolitical conflicts or technical issues, it can take as long as six months for the shipment to reach the buyer’s port.

For green coffee, this long transport time is not a problem as long as it is stored in dry, airtight conditions. For roasted coffee, however, it is a different story. It quickly loses its aroma.

We asked our master roaster and Head of Coffee, Hannes Fendrich, about this topic

Stephan Eicke: Did we ever consider having the coffee roasted at origin?

Hannes Fendrich: [Founder and Coffee Circle CEO] Martin Elwert briefly considered it. We were also explicitly approached by customers and investors who asked whether it might be even better to have the coffee roasted at origin. But there are too many challenges involved. For example, how would we handle blends, that most often contain green coffee beans from different countries? It has been proven that coffee starts to deteriorate after two weeks — that’s not a myth.

It’s a proven fact – not a myth – that coffee starts to deteriorate after two weeks. The freshest roasted coffee from Ethiopia that we could offer for sale would be three months old. But that would only be possible if everything went according to plan. So, three months after roasting, we’d have the coffee here at the earliest. I’d then have to stock more goods to ensure the roasted beans last until the next delivery. We would therefore be selling very old coffee. Furthermore, once roasted, coffee is much more sensitive to humidity and heat. The roasted coffee in the containers would be exposed to these factors for a long time. The product deteriorates.

What about the roasting facilities in the growing regions?

The Ethiopian co-operatives don’t have any roasting machines at all. In the larger cities, there are coffee shops and a few chains that handle the roasting. In Colombia and Brazil, some producers run small coffee shops attached to their fincas, which you can visit and watch the roasting process. It is more common, however, for them to supply roasters and enter into partnerships with them.

Have you ever been there and watched the coffee being roasted?

There’s a wonderful coffee shop in Addis where an elderly gentleman works – he’d be well past retirement age here. These coffee shops take a different approach, though. Their job is to roast for the local market. Ethiopians love their coffee roasted as dark as possible. It wouldn’t have been easy to define a roast profile that suits our customers. In Colombia, there’s a wider audience for lighter roasts. In Ethiopia, the beans are roasted over a fire until they’re jet black. They still taste good because they have a certain natural acidity, but if they’re then transported by sea for months on end, they become undrinkable.

After weighing the pros and cons, it quickly became clear to us that roasting at origin was not a viable option. Ultimately, it comes down to a simple calculation: if the coffee doesn’t taste good after the long journey, no one will buy it — which means roasters at origin wouldn’t benefit either.

More by Coffee Circle